Consumption
How much does carbon underfloor heating consume? Eleven meters answer.
You read everywhere that electric underfloor heating can only be supplementary heating, and that it is expensive to run. The manufacturer of the system we fit publishes its readings, building by building. Here they are, with their limits.
The figure, first
Between 15 and 50 kWh of electricity per square metre per year, for heating alone: that is the range the manufacturer publishes, with a median of around 24. It took these readings at the meter, for at least one year, in homes heated by its system.
Its table, below, runs from 17.8 to 63.8. Ten readings out of eleven lie between 18 and 36; the eleventh comes from a house built around 1900, with no insulation.
These are not our measurements: they are its own, on buildings in Germany and Austria. We reproduce them and say so.
The eleven buildings
Heating consumption alone, read at the meter over at least one year. Household electricity, hot water and ventilation are counted separately, unless stated.
| Building | Year, insulation | Area | Measured, kWh/m² per year | Energy certificate, kWh/m² per year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment block, Frankfurt | 1900, unrenovated, stone with no insulation | 95 m² | 22.8; 28.4 in a second apartment | 144 |
| Apartment block, Vienna | 1973, façade and roof uninsulated | 86 m² | 34.3, hot water included | not given |
| House, Bavaria | 2018, low-energy | 214 m² | 17.8, average over six years | 42 |
| Apartment block, Frankfurt | 1890, fully renovated | 50 m² | 17.9; 19.0 under the roof | not given |
| House near Altötting | 2022, timber frame | 173 m² | 22.6 | 44 |
| House, Strem, Austria | 2022, masonry with no external insulation | 127.5 m² | 21.0 | 42 |
| House, Litzelsdorf, Austria | 2018, central ventilation | 178 m² | 33.0 | 48 |
| House, Burgenland, Austria | around 1900, 40 cm of brick with no insulation, only the ground floor fitted | 53 m² | 63.8 | 220 |
| House, Burgenland, Austria | 2020, timber frame | 109 m² | 24.5 | 51 |
| House near Constance | 2018, ceilings up to 4.5 m | 220 m² | 32.9 | 66 |
| Apartment, Neusiedl am See, Austria | 1955, converted in 2019 | 90 m² | 36.2, at a constant 24 °C | not given |
The “energy certificate” column gives the consumption that the building’s energy certificate stated.
For the Litzelsdorf house, the manufacturer also quotes a lower reading, 24.5 kWh over the 2020-2021 season: it is the one used in its calculation against the heat pump.
The manufacturer publishes a sheet for each building, with its readings: the eleven sheets, to download from its site.
By type of building
| Building | Measured, kWh/m² per year |
|---|---|
| New, low-energy | 18 to 25 |
| Old, renovated | 18 to 36 |
| Old, unrenovated | 23 to 64 |
This grouping is the manufacturer’s. The highest value is that of the house built around 1900, where only the ground floor is fitted.
The manufacturer also quotes three readings published by a wood flooring manufacturer, over whole heating seasons: 27 kWh in a new timber-frame house, 44 in a new brick house, 62 in an old, uninsulated building.
To convert to euros, multiply by your price per kilowatt-hour: the simulator does it with the prices in your country, and compares with your current heating.
Why it is less than the calculation says
The usual rule multiplies the power by running hours: 160 W per square metre for five hours, and you arrive at 100 or 120 kWh per square metre per year. The manufacturer puts forward three reasons for the gap:
- The heating runs little. 40 to 90 minutes a day on average over the year, according to its readings; its technical data says 1 to 2 hours a day, depending on the building.
- You heat on demand, room by room. One thermostat per room, and no screed to keep warm.
- The whole surface heats. A large warm surface, rather than a small hot one.
The system is sized for this: 115 W/m² over 75 to 85% of the floor area of each room, which exceeds the room’s demand. That is what makes it possible to heat quickly, then switch off.
What these figures do not prove
- These are the manufacturer’s readings, not those of an independent body.
- The energy certificate is not a bill. It is a calculated demand, which overestimates the consumption of old buildings: the manufacturer says so itself. The gap with a real heating system would be smaller.
- Eleven buildings do not make a statistic. They show what was achieved, not what you will achieve.
- The climate matters. Frankfurt, Vienna and Bavaria are not Marseille, nor Amsterdam.
- Use matters. A home kept at a constant 24 °C consumes more: that is the last row of the table.
- A kilowatt-hour of electricity costs more than a kilowatt-hour of gas, and a heat pump uses fewer of them for the same heat. The page heat pump or carbon underfloor heating sets out the comparison.
The system’s other limits are brought together on the drawbacks page.
What about your home?
Send us your energy certificate and your bills: we tell you, before any order, which row of the table your home resembles. Describe your project.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions on this subject.
Can electric underfloor heating be the main heating?
According to the manufacturer, yes: ten of the eleven readings come from homes where it is the only heating, the eleventh from a ground floor. The oldest has been monitored since 2012. The condition is a room-by-room design, not a film laid by the metre. The rule in your country counts too: in Wallonia, Flanders, Luxembourg and the Netherlands, a text limits this choice.
Why are these figures so far from the “power × hours” rule?
Because the heating does not run five hours a day. According to the manufacturer, it runs 40 to 90 minutes a day on average over the year, 1 to 2 hours according to another of its pages, room by room, on demand.
Do I need a more powerful electricity connection or a higher contracted capacity?
For the supply connection, very rarely according to the manufacturer: not all the rooms heat at the same time, and it allows 40% of the installed power for the consumer unit and the supply connection. For the contracted capacity, the electrician checks what you have contracted at the survey.
Do these readings apply to my home?
They give an order of magnitude, not a promise. These are buildings in Germany and Austria, measured by the manufacturer itself. For your home, it takes your insulation, your climate and your bills.
What about hot water?
It is not counted, unless stated: the system heats the rooms, not the water. Hot water needs a separate water heater.
Read next
- The carbon systemA 0.45 mm carbon film that heats across its whole surface, under your floor covering. Build-up, outputs, temperatures and limits, according to the manufacturer.
- Heat pump or carbonA heat pump uses two to three times less electricity, but costs more to buy and to maintain. Independent measurements, the manufacturer's calculation, case by case.
- Fitting without screedFitting underfloor heating with no screed to break or pour: 5 mm on the existing floor, 13 to 50 mm with floor covering. Heights by floor covering, weight, time, limits.
- Carbon heating filmStriped film, fleece, paint or full-surface film: four products go by the name of carbon heating. What sets them apart, and when a simple film is enough.
Got a heat pump quote sitting on your desk?
One call, and we send you the Carbosol equivalent for the same area, on one page. Free, and without us calling you back every three days.
-
Call AndreiFrançais · English · Русский +33 6 82 57 93 38
-
Call ThomasFrançais · Deutsch +33 7 65 16 89 79
Call back within 24 hours on working days Write to us